Yesterday the San Francisco Chronicle ran a story (C.W. Nevius, "Homeless shoeshine man gets scuffed by city," June 4, 2009, San Francisco Chronicle) about a homeless man who is trying to work his way out of the street by shining shoes. Just as he had saved up enough for a room, the City's Department of Public Works informed him that he owed $491 for a street vendor license. So he started saving up for that, and continued living on the street. After the story broke, complaints rained down upon the hapless bureaucracy. By this morning, the $491 demand was deemed a "misunderstanding" and the homeless man was front-page news.
Why am I writing about this? After all, it's pretty much an everyday story: A cruel bureaucracy stomping on the little person trying to make a living. What else is new? But it made me start thinking about why we need newspapers, and we need them printed on paper.
First, we need newspapers because we need the journalists they employ. Who else is going to run this story, if not C.W. Nevius, a journalist on the staff of the Chron? No citizen journalist has the time to hunt down these stories, and certainly does not have access to a bully pulpit like a daily newspaper published in a big city paper.
Second, eReaders and computers are elitist devices. Paper newspapers are available to everyone, everywhere. You don't need to sit in front of a computer, or have the paper downloaded to your Kindle (as I admit I do). When paper newspapers disappear, only the affluent will have newspaper access. Do we want that? I don't.
By the way, the man who started me thinking about the elitism of eReaders is Sherman Alexei. At first I thought he was way wrong (he did express himself in a rather colorful manner), but now that I've been thinking about what he said, I'm worried.
The Governator also got me thinking, when he called for free digital books for California students. Does he think the books will just materialize out of thin air? Doesn't he realize that every California student will need at least a $300 computer or an eReader of similar cost to read a digital book? Of course, in the Governor's world I'm sure all kids have their own computers (and probably their own Hummers). Talk about elitist.
Recent Comments